Kirk Wetters: The Short Spring of German Theory (I): POSITIVISMUSSTREIT VS. POETIK UND HERMENEUTIK

Transatlantic Theory Canons

In present-day Germany, research on postwar academia, up through the 1960s and beyond, requires no special justification. But from the North American side, the point of this scholarly activity—including the many new editions and a flood of archive-based publications—is much less obvious. For the most well-established figures of the period, the primary international canonizations were already part of the first waves of the reception, the theoretical tectonics established themselves accordingly, and the theories were established as theories—which are in many quarters presumed to be just as reliable today as they were decades ago. One might say that the international and North American reception of European theory has manifested an overall tendency toward sedimentation, while the dynamic of scholarly research about theory, including the archival unearthing of new sources, tends to complicate and undermine the established corpus of “primary texts.” For example, not only does the quantity of new German publications on (and by) figures like Hans Blumenberg or Siegfried Kracauer widen the rift and amplify the asynchrony between North American and German academic cultures, it also heightens awareness for the fact that these somewhat “second tier” figures were extremely important all along. „Kirk Wetters: The Short Spring of German Theory (I): POSITIVISMUSSTREIT VS. POETIK UND HERMENEUTIK“ weiterlesen

Claude Haas: FRÖHLICHE WISSENSCHAFT – TRAURIGE THEORIE? Lose Bemerkungen zu einem spannungsreichen Verhältnis

Ohne Theorie? Poetik und Hermeneutik

Im Rückblick auf seine langjährige Teilnahme an den Kolloquien von Poetik und Hermeneutik, der institutionell wie theoretisch in Deutschland sicher erfolgreichsten geisteswissenschaftlichsten Gruppierung nach 1945, kam der bekannte Romanist Karlheinz Stierle jüngst auf die gemeinsamen Wurzeln der ehemaligen Mitglieder zu sprechen. Gegenteiligen Bekundungen zum Trotz dürften solche nicht etwa in einer eigenständigen »Theorie«, sie müssten vielmehr in einem bestimmten Gebrauch des Deutschen als Wissenschaftssprache gesucht werden: „Claude Haas: FRÖHLICHE WISSENSCHAFT – TRAURIGE THEORIE? Lose Bemerkungen zu einem spannungsreichen Verhältnis“ weiterlesen